This page outlines the journal-specific policies that govern manuscript evaluation, peer review, publication ethics, research integrity, clinical discipline development, healthcare management research, quality improvement, data transparency and post-publication responsibilities.
These policies should be read together with ZENTIME's publisher-level Editorial Policies, Publishing Policies, and Open Access, Fees and Licensing policies. Where journal-specific requirements supplement publisher-level policies, the requirements stated on this journal website apply.
As a journal publishing research and scholarly work on clinical discipline development, hospital and department management, healthcare quality and safety, health services research, workforce development, medical governance, clinical operations, resource allocation, health policy, implementation science and related interdisciplinary fields, the journal requires clear reporting of study design, management context, organizational data, patient and staff privacy, data governance, conflicts of interest and practical implications where applicable.
The journal expects authors, editors, reviewers and editorial board members to follow internationally recognized standards of responsible scholarly publishing, including relevant guidance from COPE, WAME, ICMJE and EQUATOR, where applicable.
The journal operates a transparent peer review process to ensure the quality, integrity, methodological rigor and practical relevance of published content.
All submitted manuscripts are first assessed by the editorial office or a handling editor for completeness, relevance to the journal's aims and scope, ethical compliance, reporting quality and suitability for further evaluation. Manuscripts that are outside the journal's scope, do not meet basic reporting standards, lack sufficient originality or raise significant ethical, privacy, organizational or methodological concerns may be declined before external peer review.
The journal uses a single-anonymous peer review model, in which reviewers remain anonymous to authors. Research articles, systematic reviews, health services studies, quality improvement reports, implementation studies, policy analyses, economic evaluations, management studies and other scholarly manuscripts requiring external review are normally assessed by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise.
For manuscripts involving hospital management, clinical discipline evaluation, quality and safety indicators, workforce studies, administrative data, institutional performance data, implementation research, health economics, digital health management tools or AI-enabled analytics, editors may invite reviewers with methodological, statistical, clinical, management, policy, ethics or data governance expertise as appropriate.
Reviewer comments are advisory. Final editorial decisions are made by the Editor-in-Chief or designated handling editor based on editorial assessment, reviewer comments, methodological rigor, originality, ethical compliance, relevance to healthcare management or clinical discipline development, and suitability for the journal.
Editorials, commentaries, letters, corrections and invited content may be reviewed internally or externally at the editors' discretion, according to the nature of the content.
Related publisher policy: ZENTIME Editorial Policies.
The journal maintains editorial independence in all editorial decisions. Decisions on individual manuscripts are made by the Editor-in-Chief, handling editors or designated editorial decision-making team in accordance with the journal's policies.
Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, originality, methodological quality, transparency, relevance to the journal's aims and scope, ethical integrity and contribution to clinical discipline development, healthcare management, quality improvement, patient safety or health policy. Decisions are not influenced by commercial interests, advertising, sponsorship, institutional affiliation, political considerations or the financial interests of ZENTIME, journal owners, editors, editorial board members, healthcare organizations, consulting companies, technology providers or any third party.
Editors and editorial board members must maintain confidentiality, declare conflicts of interest and recuse themselves from handling manuscripts where impartiality may be compromised. Manuscripts submitted by editors, editorial board members or journal staff will be handled independently by an editor without conflict of interest and will undergo the same editorial assessment and peer review standards as other submissions.
Related publisher policy: ZENTIME Editorial Policies.
The journal is committed to maintaining high standards of publication ethics and research integrity. Authors, editors and reviewers are expected to act with honesty, transparency and accountability throughout the submission, review and publication process.
The journal does not tolerate plagiarism, redundant publication, duplicate submission, data fabrication, data falsification, image manipulation, citation manipulation, authorship manipulation, peer review manipulation, paper mills or other forms of research or publication misconduct.
For healthcare management and clinical discipline research, authors must not misrepresent institutional data, management outcomes, quality indicators, patient safety events, workforce data, survey results, economic analyses, implementation outcomes, policy effects, benchmarking results or sponsor involvement.
Suspected misconduct will be assessed according to the journal's procedures and ZENTIME's publisher-level policies. Depending on the circumstances, outcomes may include a request for clarification, manuscript rejection, correction, expression of concern, retraction, article removal or notification of relevant institutions or authorities.
Related publisher policy: ZENTIME Publishing Policies.
All listed authors must have made substantial scholarly contributions to the work, approved the submitted version and agreed to its submission. The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that authorship, author order, corresponding author details and required declarations have been agreed by all authors before submission.
The journal requires an author contribution statement and encourages the use of the CRediT taxonomy where appropriate. Contributors who do not meet authorship criteria should be acknowledged with their permission.
Authors must disclose all financial and non-financial competing interests that could influence, or be perceived to influence, the work. For healthcare management research, relevant disclosures may include employment, consultancy, advisory roles, leadership positions, institutional management roles, policy advocacy positions, honoraria, grants, commercial consulting, paid training programs, management software interests, data access arrangements, statistical support, writing assistance or other relationships with hospitals, healthcare systems, universities, professional societies, government agencies, insurers, consulting firms, technology providers, quality accreditation bodies or sponsors.
All funding sources, grant numbers and institutional support should be disclosed. Authors should state the role of funders, sponsors, healthcare organizations, consulting companies or technology providers in study design, intervention development, data collection, data access, analysis, interpretation, manuscript preparation and the decision to submit for publication.
Authors should state whether they had full access to the study data and whether the sponsor, funder, institution, data provider or service provider had any role in approving or restricting publication.
Changes to authorship after submission require a clear explanation, written agreement from all authors and editorial approval.
Related publisher policy: ZENTIME Publishing Policies.
Research involving patients, healthcare professionals, managers, students, trainees, staff, caregivers, human data, institutional records, administrative data, quality indicators, patient safety reports, workforce data or identifiable organizational information must have appropriate ethics approval or exemption where required. Authors should state the name of the ethics committee or institutional review board, approval number or reference, and any relevant exemption information in the manuscript.
Healthcare management and quality improvement research may involve power relationships between managers and staff, supervisors and trainees, clinicians and patients, or institutions and employees. Authors should describe safeguards to minimize coercion, undue influence, retaliation risk, perceived obligation to participate and conflicts between employment, training, performance evaluation and research participation.
Informed consent should be obtained where required. For studies using routinely collected administrative data, quality improvement data, registry data, incident reports, performance metrics or institutional records, authors should explain the ethical, legal or governance basis for data use, including consent, waiver of consent, data use agreement, institutional approval or public availability where applicable.
Patient, staff and institutional privacy must be protected. Identifying information should not be published unless essential and properly consented. Authors should take particular care when reporting small departments, rare events, sentinel events, adverse incidents, disciplinary cases, performance rankings, workforce disputes, identifiable institutions or qualitative quotations that may allow direct or indirect identification.
Organizational confidentiality should be respected. Where institutional data are used, authors should ensure that publication is consistent with applicable ethics approval, data governance agreements, institutional permissions and participant protections.
Related publisher policy: ZENTIME Publishing Policies.
Manuscripts reporting clinical discipline development, healthcare management, quality improvement, patient safety, workforce, governance or operational studies should provide sufficient information to support evaluation, interpretation and replication.
Where applicable, authors should describe:
· organizational setting, healthcare system context and level of analysis;
· department, discipline, specialty, service line or institutional context;
· target population, staff group, patient group or management unit;
· management intervention, policy, program, pathway, governance model or operational change;
· theoretical framework, management model or implementation rationale;
· intervention components, duration, intensity, implementation process and fidelity;
· comparator, baseline period, usual practice or control condition;
· quality indicators, safety outcomes, efficiency measures, resource measures, patient outcomes, staff outcomes and equity considerations;
· data sources, indicator definitions, measurement frequency and validation procedures;
· unintended consequences, risks, workload effects and sustainability;
· factors affecting generalizability across institutions, regions or healthcare systems.
For workforce and leadership studies, authors should describe staff roles, sampling, recruitment, organizational hierarchy, confidentiality safeguards, response rates, missing data and potential non-response bias.
For patient safety studies, authors should define safety events, near misses, adverse events, incident reporting methods, severity classification, root cause analysis or risk assessment methods where applicable.
Related publisher policy: ZENTIME Publishing Policies.
Quality improvement, implementation, policy and healthcare management studies should be reported with sufficient detail to allow readers to understand what was done, why it was done, how it was implemented and how outcomes were assessed.
Authors should follow appropriate reporting guidelines according to study design. Relevant guidelines may include SQUIRE for quality improvement, StaRI for implementation studies, STROBE for observational studies, RECORD for routinely collected health data, CONSORT for randomized or cluster randomized trials, PRISMA for systematic reviews and meta-analyses, SPIRIT for trial protocols, TIDieR for intervention description, CHEERS for economic evaluations, CHERRIES for web-based surveys, COREQ or SRQR for qualitative research, GRIPP2 for patient and public involvement, AGREE or RIGHT for guidelines and other EQUATOR Network resources.
Interventional studies and clinical trials should be registered in a publicly accessible registry before participant recruitment begins where applicable. The registry name and registration number should be included in the manuscript.
Manuscripts reporting clinical trials should include a data sharing statement where required by applicable standards or journal policy. The statement should indicate whether de-identified individual participant data will be shared, what data will be shared, whether related documents such as the study protocol or statistical analysis plan will be available, when and for how long the data will be available, and the conditions for access.
For policy analyses, authors should describe the policy context, data sources, assumptions, stakeholders, implementation conditions, analytical framework and limitations. For economic evaluations, authors should describe perspective, time horizon, cost categories, valuation methods, uncertainty analysis and generalizability.
Reporting checklists and flow diagrams should be submitted where required by the journal or relevant reporting guideline.
Related publisher policy: ZENTIME Publishing Policies.
Authors should include a Data Availability Statement where applicable, describing where the data supporting the findings can be accessed or explaining why data cannot be shared.
Data, protocols, statistical analysis plans, data dictionaries, indicator definitions, survey instruments, interview guides, codebooks, analytic code, dashboards, registry specifications and supplementary materials should be made available in suitable repositories where possible and appropriate.
Restrictions due to privacy, ethics, legal requirements, institutional confidentiality, commercial sensitivity, data provider agreements, registry governance, cybersecurity, employment concerns or re-identification risks should be clearly explained.
For studies using administrative data, registry data, quality indicators, claims data, incident reports or electronic health record data, authors should describe the data source, governance arrangements, inclusion criteria, coding definitions, linkage methods, missing data, validation procedures, data quality, follow-up completeness and limitations.
For benchmarking and performance evaluation studies, authors should describe indicator selection, risk adjustment, case-mix adjustment, uncertainty estimation, ranking methods, sensitivity analyses and limitations. Authors should avoid unsupported claims about institutional performance or causality.
Supplementary materials should support the main article and should not replace essential methods, results, indicator definitions, data governance information or statistical details needed to evaluate the work.
Related publisher policy: ZENTIME Publishing Policies.
AI tools and large language models cannot be listed as authors. Authors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality and integrity of all submitted content, including any content generated or assisted by AI tools.
Use of generative AI or AI-assisted technologies beyond basic language editing should be disclosed in the manuscript according to the journal's requirements. AI tools must not be used to fabricate, falsify or manipulate data, references, management indicators, administrative data, survey responses, qualitative quotations, patient safety reports, performance metrics, images or conclusions.
For manuscripts involving AI-enabled management analytics, digital health management tools, predictive models, dashboards, decision support systems, hospital information systems, electronic health record analytics, scheduling algorithms, resource allocation tools or automated quality monitoring systems, authors should describe the intended use, system version, development and validation methods, data sources, performance metrics, workflow integration, human oversight, limitations, potential risks and safeguards where applicable.
Authors should clearly distinguish between human-generated content, AI-generated content, simulated data and real patient, staff or institutional data. Use of synthetic data, simulated cases or generated management scenarios should be disclosed and justified.
Editors and reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts, peer review reports, decision letters or related materials to public AI tools unless explicitly permitted by the journal and consistent with confidentiality and data protection requirements.
Related publisher policy: ZENTIME Publishing Policies.
The journal considers manuscripts that have been posted as preprints, provided that the work has not been formally published and is not under consideration by another journal at the same time.
Authors must disclose any preprint, conference abstract, thesis, report, quality improvement report, institutional report, policy report, government report, accreditation document, white paper, dashboard report, trial registry record or related prior dissemination at submission. Where applicable, authors should provide the preprint server name, DOI, registry link or citation.
Authors should clearly explain the relationship between the submitted manuscript and any prior version, including what is new in the submitted work. Duplicate submission and redundant publication are not permitted.
If the manuscript is accepted, authors are encouraged to update the preprint or repository record with a citation and link to the final published article.
Related publisher policy: ZENTIME Publishing Policies.
The journal is an open access journal. Published articles are made freely available online according to the journal's applicable copyright and licensing terms.
Authors should review the journal's Open Access and Fees page before submission for information on article processing charges, waiver or discount options, copyright, license terms, article sharing and self-archiving.
Authors are responsible for obtaining permission to reproduce or adapt third-party figures, tables, images, text, management frameworks, dashboards, quality indicators, survey instruments, policy documents, training materials, screenshots, software interfaces or other materials where permission is required. Article sharing, hosting and self-archiving must comply with the applicable license and ZENTIME's Open Access, Fees and Licensing policy.
Related publisher policy: ZENTIME Open Access, Fees and Licensing.
The journal is committed to maintaining the integrity and transparency of the scholarly record. Post-publication updates may include corrections, expressions of concern, retractions or article removal where appropriate.
Corrections may be issued for significant errors that do not invalidate the article. Retractions may be issued when findings are unreliable, unethical or substantially compromised. Expressions of concern may be issued when serious concerns remain unresolved.
For healthcare management research, post-publication concerns may include unreliable institutional data, undisclosed conflicts of interest, misrepresented quality indicators, inaccurate performance claims, privacy breaches, inappropriate use of staff or patient data, undisclosed sponsor influence, fabricated qualitative data, invalid economic analyses or other issues that may affect organizational, clinical, policy or public health interpretation.
Authors may appeal an editorial decision or submit a complaint by contacting the Editorial Office. Appeals should identify specific concerns, such as a possible error in the editorial process, a misunderstanding of the manuscript or evidence that relevant information was not adequately considered.
Appeals do not guarantee reconsideration, external review or reversal of the original decision. Repeated appeals without new evidence may not be considered. Complaints regarding editorial conduct, peer review, conflicts of interest, confidentiality or publication ethics will be handled fairly, confidentially and in a timely manner.
Related publisher policies: ZENTIME Editorial Policies and ZENTIME Publishing Policies.
Related ZENTIME publisher policies:
· Editorial Policies
· Publishing Policies
· Open Access, Fees and Licensing
Related external standards and resources may include:
· Committee on Publication Ethics
· World Association of Medical Editors
· International Committee of Medical Journal Editors
· EQUATOR Network
· SQUIRE
· StaRI
· STROBE
· RECORD
· CONSORT
· PRISMA
· SPIRIT
· TIDieR
· CHEERS
· CHERRIES
· COREQ
· SRQR
· GRIPP2
· AGREE
· RIGHT